| William MacDonald | 1914-1916 | Wilbur J. Pester | 1964 | |
| John D. Paynter | 1917-1918 | William P. O'Brien | 1965 | |
| George W. Oberlander | 1918-1919 | Alvin A. Adams | 1966 | |
| Roscoe P. Paynter | 1919-1920 | Wallace E. Schaab | 1967 | |
| Howard C. Opdyke | 1920-1921 | Franklyn W. Jackson | 1968 | |
| Charles Redfern | 1921-1922 | Emil R. Dean | 1969 | |
| Clinton B. Lohsen | 1923-1924 | John Gorski | 1970 | |
| William Turner Jr. | 1925 | John J. Armstrong | 1971 | |
| Herbert E. Stanford | 1926 | Douglas F. Foulks | 1972 | |
| Walter H. Klepp | 1927 | Thomas B. O'Brien | 1973 | |
| Richard A. Jessen | 1928 | William Riley | 1974 | |
| Peter McGrath | 1929 | Gary M. Dethiefsen | 1975 | |
| Rudolph L. Vogel | 1930 | Walter E. Stiesi | 1976 | |
| Wiliam Balbach, Sr. | 1931 | William P. Slover | 1977 | |
| Louis F. Ruhman | 1932 | John F. Schulite | 1978 | |
| Edward Goff | 1933 | Richard S. Hausner | 1979 | |
| Eugene J. Knowles | 1934 | John J. Murray | 1980 | |
| Alphonsus McGrath | 1935 | Frank DiGangi | 1981 | |
| Richard J. Trenery | 1936 | Williamn Jacques | 1982 | |
| Frank Walters | 1937 | Fank DiGennaro | 1983 | |
| Raymond B. Truax | 1938 | William Riley | 1984 | |
| Robert Helfrich | 1939 | John Feehan | 1985 | |
| Edwin G. Herrmann | 1940 | Albert Scott Sr. | 1986 | |
| Paul V. Fucci | 1941 | Kevin J. McNulty | 1987 | |
| Frederick W. Foerster | 1942 | Carmen Falco | 1988 | |
| Arthur Buerkle, Sr. | 1943 | Richard Agar | 1989 | |
| George W. Sullivan | 1944 | Richard Walters | 1990 | |
| Andrew Mularchuk | 1945 | Raymond B. O'Hare | 1991 | |
| Frank Jackson | 1946 | Michael Allfrey | 1992 | |
| Harold M. Haitsch | 1947 | James Pigott | 1993 | |
| Layton A. Webster | 1948 | James Falco | 1994 | |
| Gerald Broander | 1949 | Michael Pigott | 1995 | |
| Raymond B Stryker | 1950 | Timothy Kauffmann | 1996 | |
| August Vogel | 1951 | Steve Cosgriff | 1997 | |
| Andrew D. Snellgrove, Sr | 1952 | Michael Thomspon | 1998 | |
| George Spafford | 1953 | Raymond B. O'Hare | 1999 | |
| John D. Kite | 1954 | Andrew Murray | 2000 | |
| William Balbach, Jr | 1955 | Brian Pigott | 2001 | |
| Charles Quackenbush | 1956 | Scot Smit | 2002 | |
| Edward Plunkett | 1957 | Steve Rogan | 2003 | |
| Theodore Loder | 1958 | Robert Dester | 2004 | |
| William Snyder | 1959 | Joseph Bellotti | 2005 | |
| Martin C. Lohsen | 1960 | Kevin Rogers | 2006 | |
| Charles E. Gee | 1961 | James Merkel | 2007 | |
| Robert W. Schwing | 1962 | Albert D. Scott III | 2008 | |
| Charles H. Thomas | 1963 | Arthur Boden | 2009 |